Or Sign In With

Create an account and get $150 discount immediately!

Searchproducts Search

Quick search:

  • My Wish List
  • My Cart 0

Affordable Engagement Rings Under $5,000

Filter

Items 861-880 of 886

Page
  1. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    Platinum GIA Certified 1.11 Carat Princess Cut Engagement Ring Set
    PRE-OWNED
    Platinum GIA Certified 1.11 Carat Princess Cut Engagement Ring Set
    0  Reviews
    $3,257.00 $8,900.00
  2. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    Princess cut VS2, 14K white gold two-piece set with 39 diamonds, 5 DWT
    PRE-OWNED
    Princess cut VS2, 14K white gold two-piece set with 39 diamonds, 5 DWT
    0  Reviews
    $3,550.00 $6,350.00
  3. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    18KYG Wedding Set 3 Stone Engagement Ring 4 Stone Band 1.19CT Total
    PRE-OWNED
    18KYG Wedding Set 3 Stone Engagement Ring 4 Stone Band 1.19CT Total
    0  Reviews
    $4,900.00 $6,000.00
  4. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    1.51 round brilliant diamond engagement ring with diamond wedding band
    PRE-OWNED
    1.51 round brilliant diamond engagement ring with diamond wedding band
    0  Reviews
    $4,300.00 $6,600.00
  5. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    3 Stone Engagement Ring, 11 Stone Wedding Band, White Gold
    PRE-OWNED
    3 Stone Engagement Ring, 11 Stone Wedding Band, White Gold
    0  Reviews
    $2,240.00 $3,200.00
  6. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    1.625 TCW - 1.00 CT ROUND LEO ARTISAN DIAMOND 14K WHITE GOLD SET
    PRE-OWNED
    1.625 TCW - 1.00 CT ROUND LEO ARTISAN DIAMOND 14K WHITE GOLD SET
    0  Reviews
    $4,200.00 $8,350.00
  7. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    .8 carat Round Solitaire,14K white gold band & 1 carat diam. inhancer
    PRE-OWNED
    .8 carat Round Solitaire,14K white gold band & 1 carat diam. inhancer
    0  Reviews
    $4,200.00 $6,200.00
  8. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    2.12 Neil Lane engagment ring and matching 1/2 carat wedding band
    PRE-OWNED
    2.12 Neil Lane engagment ring and matching 1/2 carat wedding band
    0  Reviews
    $3,875.00 $9,500.00
  9. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    .75 Carat Round Brilliant Engagement Ring with Matching Diamond Band
    PRE-OWNED
    .75 Carat Round Brilliant Engagement Ring with Matching Diamond Band
    0  Reviews
    $3,800.00 $5,249.00
  10. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    .82 C Pear Brilliant Cut, fancy light gray, SI1 wedding set
    PRE-OWNED
    .82 C Pear Brilliant Cut, fancy light gray, SI1 wedding set
    0  Reviews
    $2,990.00 $5,000.00
  12. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    Ashcroft&Oak diamond engagement ring with kay jewelers 10k gold band
    PRE-OWNED
    Ashcroft&Oak diamond engagement ring with kay jewelers 10k gold band
    0  Reviews
    $2,100.00 $2,300.00
  13. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    1.52tcw Leo Diamond in a Neil Lane Setting with Matching Band
    PRE-OWNED
    1.52tcw Leo Diamond in a Neil Lane Setting with Matching Band
    0  Reviews
    $3,100.00 $5,150.00
  14. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    Stunning ring for a true princess
    PRE-OWNED
    Stunning ring for a true princess
    0  Reviews
    $2,800.00 $3,995.00
  16. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    Princess Cut 0.82 Carat Engagement Ring Set 1.83tcw
    PRE-OWNED
    Princess Cut 0.82 Carat Engagement Ring Set 1.83tcw
    0  Reviews
    $4,800.00 $10,800.00
  17. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    Stackable Wedding Ring Set
    PRE-OWNED
    Stackable Wedding Ring Set
    0  Reviews
    $4,900.00 $6,500.00
  18. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    Vintage 0.60ct Cushion Cut Diamond Bridal Ring Set 14k Yellow Gold 1.25tcw
    PRE-OWNED
    Vintage 0.60ct Cushion Cut Diamond Bridal Ring Set 14k Yellow Gold 1.25tcw
    0  Reviews
    $3,464.00 $6,464.00
  19. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    0.85ct Cushion Twisted Accents Diamond Bridal Set in 14k Rose Gold 1.50tcw
    PRE-OWNED
    0.85ct Cushion Twisted Accents Diamond Bridal Set in 14k Rose Gold 1.50tcw
    0  Reviews
    $4,899.00 $6,899.00
  20. NATURAL DIAMOND
    Add to Wish List
    2tcw Cushion With Princess Cut Diamond Wedding Ring Set
    PRE-OWNED
    2tcw Cushion With Princess Cut Diamond Wedding Ring Set
    0  Reviews
    $4,399.00 $6,399.00
Shop By
Filters
Side Stone Weigh
Shape
swatch Round
swatch Princess
swatch Oval
swatch Cushion
swatch Emerald
swatch Pear
swatch Radiant
swatch Marquise
swatch Heart
swatch Asscher
swatch Trillion
Size
M
XS
S
L
XL
36
37
38
39
Total Carat Weight
Stone Color
Clarity
Price
Certification
swatch IGI
swatch GIA
swatch AGI
swatch Non
swatch GSI
swatch EGL
swatch AGS
swatch TIFFANY
swatch HRD
Brand
Metal
swatch White Gold 14K
swatch White Gold 18K
swatch Platinum
swatch Yellow Gold 14K
swatch Other
swatch Yellow Gold 18K
swatch Rose Gold
swatch White Gold 10K
swatch White Gold 14
swatch Yellow Gold 10K
swatch White Gold
swatch Silver
swatch Sterling Silver
Material
Gender

Pre-owned Engagement Rings Under $5,000

There’s nothing more beautiful than finding the perfect engagement ring — except finding the perfect engagement ring for a fraction of the retail price! If you’re looking for affordable engagement rings under $5,000, be sure to browse our collection today.

#haveyouseenthering

Explore our Instagram for a glimpse into the captivating allure of our luxurious jewelry. Join us on this journey and be inspired by the epitome of refined beauty.

Follow us @haveyouseenthering

Free Shipping

Free Shipping for orders over $150

Money Back Guarantee

Within 30 days for an exchange.

Online Support

24 hours a day, 7 days a week

Flexible Payments

Pay with Multiple Methods

Consult with a Jewelry Specialist

Experience personalized guidance and expertise with our Consult with a Jewelry Specialist service. Our team of knowledgeable specialists is here to assist you in selecting the perfect piece, answering your questions, and offering tailored advice.

Book an appointment